A brake caliper gets replaced during a PM visit at a shop in Dallas. Seven weeks later the same truck is rolling through Ohio when that caliper fails and the truck goes out of service. The nearest shop can fix it. The question is who pays.
Two decisions made in Dallas settle that. The first was whether to install an OEM or an aftermarket caliper. The second was whether the invoice recorded the part number, the supplier and the warranty terms, or just said "brake caliper, aftermarket." If it is the second, the fleet pays for a part that may still have been under warranty, because nobody can prove otherwise. That same missing detail is what FMCSA auditors look for in maintenance records, so a vague work order fails twice. This guide covers both decisions: which parts to buy OEM and which aftermarket, and what has to be in writing before the part goes on the truck.
An OEM part is made by the truck's original equipment manufacturer, or by the supplier that built the original part to the truck maker's specifications. Order through a Kenworth, Peterbilt, Freightliner or Volvo dealer and that is generally what you get: the same tolerances, materials and performance standards as the part that came on the truck.
Aftermarket parts are made by third parties to fit and work in place of the OEM part. Quality varies widely by manufacturer and category. A top-tier brake supplier like Bendix or Haldex is not the same as an unknown overseas brand selling at a fraction of the OEM price, and in commercial trucking, where a failed part can mean an out-of-service order or a crash, that difference matters more than in any other vehicle segment.
One nuance changes the math in many categories. A share of aftermarket filters, electrical parts and suspension hardware is made by the same suppliers that produce the OEM version. The part is functionally identical; it just comes in a different box without the truck maker's logo, at a lower price. Knowing when you are in that situation, and when you are looking at a genuinely inferior substitute, is the real skill in parts buying.
An OEM-everything policy feels like the lowest-risk choice, and for a small fleet with a few high-value units it removes one source of variability. It also costs real money on high-volume consumables, where reputable aftermarket parts match OEM performance at a lower price. The better approach is neither blanket policy but a choice made by component, based on safety, warranty status and cost per mile.
Brakes are where the case for OEM is strongest. Brake problems made up 39.1% of all vehicle out-of-service violations in CVSA's 2026 International Roadcheck, and the cost of an inferior brake part is a liability exposure, not just a replacement cost. Jason Dolence, manager of parts and warranty at LTL carrier Pitt Ohio, told Fleet Maintenance the company does not deviate from OE replacement components on braking systems, linings and shoes included, because braking is a primary safety function. Pitt Ohio runs most of its trucks to a million miles or more.
Some premium aftermarket brake suppliers do meet or exceed OEM specifications. If one has documented performance data, a credible warranty and a record with comparable fleets, there is a case for it, but the decision should rest on data, not purchase price.
Filters are one of the clearest cases for aftermarket. Brands like Donaldson, Baldwin and Wix have long track records with filtration ratings and service life that match OEM. The caveat is warranty: while a truck is inside its factory powertrain coverage, stay with OEM or an approved equivalent on anything that could be linked to an engine failure (more on why below). After coverage ends, reputable aftermarket filters are a sound saving, and an oil analysis program lets you confirm the filter and oil combination is performing with evidence rather than assumption.
Shocks, springs, bushings and U-bolts wear gradually and rarely fail catastrophically, but poor parts speed up tire wear, affect handling and cause alignment problems that cost money elsewhere. The aftermarket has strong suspension suppliers, some of which outlast stock parts under heavy loads. The risk is at the cheap end: a shock that needs replacing at 80,000 miles instead of 150,000 is not a saving.
Lighting is a good aftermarket category. The commercial lighting aftermarket is mature, with LED and conventional replacements that meet DOT and FMVSS standards, and lighting violations are among the most common at roadside, so keeping lamps working matters more than the brand on the box. Electronics are different. ECMs, sensors and anything that touches emissions aftertreatment depend on precise fitment and software compatibility, and cheap aftermarket sensors can throw fault codes, cause derates or send technicians chasing problems that cost far more than the part saved. Ernest Acevedo, director of fleet maintenance at Boyle Transportation, told Fleet Maintenance he is wary of moving away from OE on core engine components, which he described as capable of causing "a lot of headaches and unscheduled repairs."
No fleet buys replacement tires from the truck maker, so the real tire decision is application and cost per mile: matching the tire to the duty cycle matters more than the brand. Mud flaps, mirrors, toolboxes, cab accessories, wiper blades and general hardware are almost always aftermarket buys, since they do not affect safety or the drivetrain and the price gap can be large with no difference in service life.
Rather than one rule for every part, sort components into tiers so the purchasing decision is made once, not at every repair.
Tier 1, safety-critical: OEM or certified equivalent. Brakes, steering, fifth wheel assemblies and electrical safety systems. Any part whose failure in service creates a safety event or an out-of-service violation. Document what was installed and when.
Tier 2, performance-critical: aftermarket only from suppliers with a track record. Engine and transmission components, emissions parts, suspension. Aftermarket is acceptable from suppliers with documented quality standards and warranties, judged on performance over several PM cycles, not price.
Tier 3, consumables and wear parts: aftermarket preferred. Filters (after warranty), lighting, wipers, cab hardware and accessories, bought from reputable suppliers on total cost.
| Component | Recommended approach |
|---|---|
| Brakes (friction, hardware, chambers) | OEM or certified equivalent only |
| Steering and fifth wheel | OEM |
| Engine and transmission components | OEM during warranty; Tier 2 evaluation after |
| Emissions and ECM components | OEM or OEM-equivalent |
| Suspension (shocks, springs, bushings) | Reputable aftermarket, backed by data |
| Tires | Match to duty cycle; brand secondary |
| Filters (oil, air, fuel) | Reputable aftermarket after warranty |
| Lighting and electrical accessories | Aftermarket preferred |
| Cab accessories and hardware | Aftermarket |
Before switching a category from OEM to aftermarket, run a pilot. Acevedo's approach at Boyle is to keep the PM schedule unchanged and test the new part across two or three PM intervals, judging it on durability and dependability rather than price. Track failure rate against the OEM baseline, miles to replacement, shop labor and any fault codes. Michael Dominguez of Transervice put the risk of skipping that step plainly: "Without a good system, you might assume a part is working properly because you haven't heard any complaints."
Many fleet managers know the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act from passenger cars: a manufacturer cannot void a consumer warranty just because an aftermarket part was used, and the burden is on the manufacturer to prove the part caused the failure. That protection is real for consumer products. It does not extend to commercial trucks. As Marc Karon of the Commercial Vehicle Solutions Network put it in a Heavy Duty Trucking commentary, the same protection does not apply to commercial vehicles, and a manufacturer's warranty may be denied simply because the owner did not source the part from an authorized dealer.
That changes the rule for trucks still under OEM coverage. On any system covered by the factory warranty, an aftermarket part gives the OEM grounds to deny a claim on that system, so the safe choice is OEM or a documented OEM-approved equivalent, with complete records. Once a truck is out of OEM coverage, which describes most of a Class 8 truck's working life, aftermarket parts are standard practice, and the only warranty on the part is the aftermarket supplier's own.
Aftermarket parts for Class 8 trucks typically carry warranties from 12 months up to limited lifetime coverage, depending on component and supplier. Truck Parts and Service's reporting on how suppliers set warranty length found that major suppliers such as Eaton, Dana and Horton generally parallel OEM terms, because their parts are built and tested to OEM specifications.
That warranty is only as good as the paperwork. A part that was installed but not identified cannot be claimed against anyone. A complete record for a single replacement includes:
An invoice without those details is a billing record, not a warranty document. The same detail is what 49 CFR Part 396 expects in maintenance records, so a shop that gets it right protects both the warranty claim and the audit.
Even with a valid warranty and complete records, a truck that crosses state lines hits a second problem: the claim has to be honored at a shop that is not the installing shop, often hundreds of miles away. SelecTrucks, which runs nationwide truck warranty programs, describes the result when nationwide repair access is missing: the fleet pays for the repair and tries to recover the cost afterward, with approval, timing and paperwork all out of its hands. The Heavy Duty Parts Report lists national warranty coverage among the first questions to put to any parts supplier.
The test is simple. Before the part is installed, ask the supplier whether the warranty can be processed at any licensed repair facility in the United States or only at an authorized shop in its network. If there are network limits, know them before the truck leaves the region.
Warranty claims do not process automatically. Chad Lucky of National Truck Protection told Commercial Carrier Journal: "If you haven't been maintaining the truck properly, it will void your warranty." Providers ask for PM records with the claim, including VIN, service dates and mileage, to confirm the truck was maintained to the warranty's terms before the failure. A fleet whose records are whatever each shop happened to produce is exposed twice: to the auditor and to the claims reviewer, through the same gaps.
That is why consistent documentation is worth more than any single parts decision. A coordinated truck PM service that produces the same record at every shop builds the history warranty claims depend on and the file FMCSA auditors check, at the same time.
The cleanest test for any parts choice is cost per mile, not unit price. A brake shoe that costs $40 instead of $65 is not a saving if it lasts 80,000 miles instead of 130,000, and certainly not if it takes the truck out of service at mile 95,000 for a roadside repair. The same math applies to filters, shocks and belts. Tracking cost per mile, miles to replacement and labor per repair event shows which choices are actually working, and gives you the evidence when someone asks why the fleet pays more for certain parts.
Buying ahead of demand helps too. Parts sourced before a seasonal rush are cheaper and easier to find than parts sourced under breakdown pressure; what to put on the shelf before winter is covered in the parts section of the winter preventive maintenance guide, and what to check when vetting a supplier for several makes is in how to vet a truck parts supplier for a mixed-brand fleet.
The cheapest part at purchase is not the goal; the lowest total cost of keeping the truck in revenue service is. That takes the right part in the right tier and a record that makes its warranty claimable wherever it fails. Our truck parts and tires program supplies OEM and quality aftermarket parts through vetted shops in 48 states, at negotiated pricing and with the part-level documentation a warranty claim needs. To see how that would work across your makes and lanes, send your fleet profile through the contact page.
This article draws on the following sources: